Skip to main content

PL investigation of City more serious than that by Uefa

The authoritative Swiss Ramble takes a 'deep dive' into the Premier League's charges against Manchester City: https://swissramble.substack.com/p/manchester-city-charged-by-the-premier

The scale of the accusation is unprecedented, adding up to more than 100 charges.  Basically, it is claimed that City have over-stated sponsorship revenue and under-stated costs in order to improve their bottom line, thus helping them to stay within FFP targets, either by boosting profits or reducing losses.

Although many commentators have presented this as a Financial Fair Play (FFP) issue, the fundamental allegation is a lot more serious, namely that City have “cooked the books” by submitting false accounts for the best part of a decade. If true, this would amount to systematic cheating and have huge implications for the club.

One of the accusations levelled at City is that commercial operations account for an unhealthy proportion of total revenue at 51%, but it is worth noting that PSG and Bayern are both a fair but higher with 59% and 58% respectively.

One of the accusations against Financial Fair Play is that it establishes a “glass ceiling” for aspirational clubs, thus cementing the status of the traditional elite. Survival of the fattest, if you will. This makes it extremely difficult for clubs like Manchester City, who were starting from a low base when ADUG arrived. The strategy of the new ownership in 2008 was obvious: make significant investment in the club, both the playing squad and infrastructure, which would lead to large short-term financial losses, but ultimately deliver profitability via the rewards of on-pitch success.

Many will assume that this is a waste of time, expecting a similar result to the previous UEFA case, but there are some important differences which might give this investigation more teeth:

  • The Premier League has spent over four years looking at City’s accounts, so they should be far better prepared than UEFA were.
  • No restrictions on source of evidence, which theoretically means that documents obtained by the Portuguese hacker are fully admissible.
  • No possibility of City taking the case to CAS if the judgment goes against them.
  • Evidence is not time-barred (though the case would presumably be governed by English law)

Are these accusations very serious? Definitely.  Will City be found guilty? Maybe.

 


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Threat of financial calamity removed from Baggies

West Bromwich Albion had effectively been in decline ever since the club was sold to a Chinese consortium in August 2016, paying a figure north of £200m to buy former owner Jeremy Peace’s stake. Controlling shareholder Guochuan Lai’s ownership was fairly disastrous for the club, but his unloved tenure finally came to an end after Bilkul Football WBA, a company ultimately owned by Florida-based entrepreneur Shilen Patel and his father Dr Kiran Patel, acquired an 87.8% shareholding in West Bromwich Albion Group Limited, the parent company of West Bromwich Albion Football Club. This change in ownership was urgently required, due to the numerous financial problems facing West Brom, including growing high-interest debt and serious cash flow concerns, following years of no investment from the former owner. Indeed, West Brom’s auditors had already rung the alarm bell in the 2021/22 accounts when they cast doubt on the club’s ability to continue as a going concern without making player s...
1 comment
Read more

Gold standard ground boosts Tottenham's income

The gold standard in European football grounds is the Tottenham Hotspur stadium in north London, a £1bn construction project completed in 2019. Its impact on the club’s finances has become increasingly clear as the effects of the pandemic have faded. Previously, the average fan would spend less than £2 inside the ground on a typical match day, but now that figure is about £16, thanks to new facilities including the longest bar in Europe and an on-site microbrewery. Capacity has gone up from 36,000 at the club’s previous home of White Hart Lane to 62,000.  The new stadium — built on land adjacent to White Hart Lane — has opened the door to a broad range of other events that have helped to push commercial income up from €117mn in 2018 to €215mn in 2022. Last year, Tottenham hosted US singer Beyoncé for five nights on her global Renaissance tour, two NFL matches, as well as rugby games and heavyweight boxing bouts.  Money brought in from football has gone up too. Match day ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Spurs to sell minority stake

Tottenham Hotspur is in talks to sell a minority stake in a deal that could value it at up to £3.75 billion and pave the way for Joe Lewis and his family to sever ties with the Premier League football club. Tottenham chairman Daniel Levy is seeking an investment that values the club at between £3.5 billion and £3.75 billion, including debt. While the terms of any deal have not been finalised, City sources expect Spurs to sell about 10 per cent. The club is being advised by bankers from Rothschild on the sale. Tottenham wants to raise fresh capital for new player signings and to help fund the development of an academy for its women’s team, as well as a 30-storey hotel next to its north London stadium. The financier Amanda Staveley, who brokered the deal for Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund to take over Newcastle United, is understood to be among the parties to have expressed an interest in Tottenham. Staveley’s fund, PCP Capital Partners, has raised about £500 million to ...
Post a Comment
Read more