Skip to main content

Pompey's road to recovery and the challenges ahead

It has taken 12 years, two administrations and three points deductions, but Portsmouth will be back in the Championship next season after clinching the League One title under the impressive young coach John Mousinho, who replaced Danny Cowley in January 2023.

Up until 2010, Pompey had enjoyed seven seasons in the Premier League, winning the FA Cup in 2008, then playing in the UEFA Cup, before suffering three relegations in just four seasons, ending up in League Two. They spent four seasons in England’s fourth tier, before securing promotion to League One in 2017, while it took them another seven years to get back to the Championship.

It has taken 12 years, two administrations and three points deductions, but Portsmouth will be back in the Championship next season after clinching the League One title under the impressive young coach John Mousinho, who replaced Danny Cowley in January 2023.

Up until 2010, Pompey had enjoyed seven seasons in the Premier League, winning the FA Cup in 2008, then playing in the UEFA Cup, before suffering three relegations in just four seasons, ending up in League Two. They spent four seasons in England’s fourth tier, before securing promotion to League One in 2017, while it took them another seven years to get back to the Championship.

Portsmouth’s rise to the top flight had been bankrolled by Serbian-American businessman Milan Mandaric, but the club really started to spend money like it was going out of fashion after it was acquired by French-Israeli business man Sacha Gaydamak in 2006

Things looked good for a while, but they took a major turn for the worse in the 2009/10 season, when Portsmouth somehow went through four different owners. They kicked-off the new campaign under Gaydamak, son of the colourful Arcadi, who was accused of making money from illegal arms deals.

Having apparently been badly impacted by the credit crunch, in August 2009 Gaydamak decided to sell the club to Sulaiman Al-Fahim, the self-proclaimed power broker behind Abu Dhabi United Group’s takeover of Manchester City.

However, just 40 days later Al-Fahim gave up trying to find the money to complete the purchase and sold his shares to Ali al-Faraj, who was actually never seen at Fratton Park. According to reports at the time, he was some sort of commodity broker, but however he made his money, precious little of it found its way to the South coast.

The resultant financial difficulties meant that Balram Chainrai took ownership, but this seemed to be more a case of an exasperated creditor attempting to protect himself and/or pick up Portsmouth’s major asset (the ground) on the cheap.

Either way, Chainrai put the club into administration, thus triggering a nine-point penalty, which effectively confirmed the club’s relegation from the Premier League (though they did manage to reach the FA Cup final, where they lost 1-0 to Chelsea).

A year later, the club was sold yet again, this time to a Russian businessman, Vladimir Antonov, though he ended up being convicted of fraud in his home country. Meanwhile, the club went into administration for the second time in two years, leading to a 10-point deduction and relegation to League One.

The club’s financial issues led to another 10-point penalty, confirming another relegation, this time to League Two.

It’s not overly dramatic to say that at this point Portsmouth were close to going out of existence, but they were saved by the fans, as the Supporters Trust took ownership of the club in April 2013.

They inherited a club with no training ground, no kit deal, no commercial agreements and indeed no players, so it’s been a long way back. However, the Trust managed to steady the ship, before Portsmouth began the slow road to recovery. This was a great example of a club doing well under fan ownership.

However, in August 2017 the Trust approved the sale of the club to Tornante, an American company headed by former Disney chief executive Michael Eisner, as it felt that Portsmouth needed an owner with deeper pockets. Tornante paid around £6m and invested £10m in equity.

2022/23 accounts

Portsmouth’s loss slightly widened from £2.9m to £3.1m, despite revenue rising £0.6m (5%) from £11.9m to £12.5m and a £0.9m improvement in player sales, which swung from a £0.2m loss to £0.7m profit. However, this was offset by a steep increase in operating expenses, which rose £1.6m (11%) from £14.8m to £16.4m.

Portsmouth saw revenue growth in both match day, up £0.5m (8%) from £5.3m to £5.8m, and commercial, up £0.4m (14%) from £3.4m to £3.8m. On the other hand, broadcasting fell £0.4m (11%) from £3.3m to £2.9m.

Portsmouth’s £3.1m loss was mid-table in League One, significantly lower than Derby County £30.4m, Ipswich Town £18.2m and Charlton Athletic £9.6m. Only one club managed to generate a profit last season, namely Exeter City – and that was just £0.3m.

Portsmouth’s £12.5m revenue is the highest since the club returned from administration and is up £3.6m (41%) compared to their first season after promotion to League One in 2017/18. Since then, there has been good growth in all three revenue streams: commercial rose 75% (£1.6m), broadcasting 37% (£0.8m) and ticket sales 26% (£1.2m).

In contrast to England’s top two divisions, broadcasting has the lowest revenue share at just 23%, while match day leads the way with 46%, followed by commercial 31%.

Revenue will obviously increase next season following promotion to the Championship, mainly thanks to the higher TV deal, but also from likely increases in gate receipts and sponsorships.  However, Portsmouth will still find themselves a long way below leading clubs in the Championship. Clubs recently relegated from the Premier League earned at least £65m in 2022/23, i.e. more than three times as much as Pompey’s likely income in the higher division.

TV money will shoot up to at least £8m in the Championship next season. There is also a new 5-year deal with Sky starting in 2024/25, which represents a 50% increase on the current agreement.

Crowds have grown to just under 19,000 this season, driven by the team’s success, so they are at their highest since the last time that Pompey were in the Premier League back in 2009/10.

Wages

Portsmouth’s wages rose £0.4m from £7.9m to £8.3m, just ahead of the club’s previous League One peak of £8.1m in 2019/20. In fact, they have held wages at around the £8m level for the past four years.  As a result of this restraint, Portsmouth’s £8.3m wage bill was only eighth highest in League One, a long way behind Ipswich Town £19.8m, Derby County £17.2m and Sheffield Wednesday £15.8m, though two of those were inflated by promotion bonuses.

Of course, Portsmouth will have to spend a lot more on wages in the Championship if they hope to be competitive. In 2022/23 clubs receiving parachute payments averaged over £50m, while the non-parachute clubs paid an average of £23m.

Portsmouth spent £1.5m on player purchases in 2022/23, which was not a massive outlay, but was twice as much as the previous season and actually the second highest outlay since promotion to League One (only behind the £2.3m in 2019/20).

Debt and funding

Portsmouth are essentially debt-free with only £15k of finance leases. The club had inherited £10.5m debt as part of the administration process, but this was very largely repaid in 2014, two years ahead of schedule, as a result of negotiating significant savings.  In stark contrast some of the clubs in League One carried a lot of debt, particularly Sheffield Wednesday £57m, Derby County £36m, Fleetwood Town £33m, Charlton Athletic £28m and Oxford United £27m.

The £9m funding in 2022/23 took the amount that the current owners have put in to the club to £28m, while a further £9m was provided after these accounts, so the total is now up to £35m. They have averaged annual contributions of more than £7m over the last four seasons.

It is true that their owners have put in a lot of money, but the vast majority has been used to invest in the club’s infrastructure to repair years of neglect with very little spent on the squad.

No club has a divine right to play at a certain level, but most would think that Pompey belong in the Championship (at least). This season’s promotion should be savoured, but Portsmouth will now face the challenge of competing against clubs with much higher budgets.

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Wolves get raw deal from FFP

  I used to see a lifelong Wolves fan for lunch once a month.   He was approaching ninety, but still went to games.   Sadly he passed away the other week. As football finance guru Kieran Maguire has noted, Wolves continue to be constrained by financial fair play rules.  Radio 4 this morning described them as this year's 'crisis club' and the pessimists have certainly been piling in. Martin Samuel wrote sympathetically in the Sunday Times yesterday, saying that the Premier League drives talent away with regulatory red tape: 'Why could Al-Hilal sign Neves? Because Wolves needed the money. And why did Wolves need the money? Because the club had to comply with an artificial construct known as financial fair play. So Wolves are going skint, yes? No. There is no suggestion that Wolves are in financial trouble, only that they are failing to meet the rigours of FFP. Wolves’ owners appear to have the money to run the club, and invest in the club, and in fact came up with a pow

Gold standard ground boosts Tottenham's income

The gold standard in European football grounds is the Tottenham Hotspur stadium in north London, a £1bn construction project completed in 2019. Its impact on the club’s finances has become increasingly clear as the effects of the pandemic have faded. Previously, the average fan would spend less than £2 inside the ground on a typical match day, but now that figure is about £16, thanks to new facilities including the longest bar in Europe and an on-site microbrewery. Capacity has gone up from 36,000 at the club’s previous home of White Hart Lane to 62,000.  The new stadium — built on land adjacent to White Hart Lane — has opened the door to a broad range of other events that have helped to push commercial income up from €117mn in 2018 to €215mn in 2022. Last year, Tottenham hosted US singer Beyoncé for five nights on her global Renaissance tour, two NFL matches, as well as rugby games and heavyweight boxing bouts.  Money brought in from football has gone up too. Match day income is

Charlton takeover approved

The long awaited takeover of Charlton Athletic by SE7 Partners from Thomas Sandgaard has been approved:  https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/se7-partners-obtain-efl-approval-for-charlton-athletic-takeover/ Charlton have had unhappy experiences with owners for over a decade, so how this works out will remain to be seen.  There is certainly potential there, but will it be realised? This interview with Charlie Methven gives detail not available elsewhere:  https://thecharltondossier.com/charlie-methven-on-the-record/