When a small group of staff were told of Monchi’s exit from Aston Villa on Monday afternoon, they were startled to learn one of Villa’s most senior figures, and a renowned football executive, had departed.
Players left training earlier in the day and only learned of
the news when The Athletic broke the story hours later. Wider
staff not directly involved in Monchi’s departments, including senior figures,
were equally surprised. They acknowledged that Villa’s recruitment had been
poor and tensions were developing, but not quite to the extent of Monchi
leaving just over a month into the new season.
The exact framing of that departure depends on who you ask.
For some, it was a matter of necessity on the back of the summer’s transfer
struggle; others present it as a mutual decision, while there are also personal
reasons for Monchi wanting to return to Spain.
Monchi is expected to remain in an advisory capacity within
Villa’s ownership group, V Sports, as part of plans to restructure the football
department. This indicates the relationship between him and the ownership group
remains good.
The fact that Villa have moved swiftly for Roberto
Olabe, the former Real Sociedad sporting director, who played for Emery’s
boyhood club, Real Union, underlines that his was not a knee-jerk decision.
Olabe was on Villa’s radar before they hired Monchi and has also been
considered by Arsenal and Real Madrid.
Monchi and Vidagany often travelled to London to meet with
co-owner Nassef Sawiris when he still resided in the United Kingdom. The pair
were responsible for keeping Sawiris and fellow co-owner Wes Edens briefed
while helping direct them on decisions.
Sawiris is the more involved figure on the football side and
is hugely ambitious. He wants to compete regularly in the Champions League
and has long championed Emery’s project, allowing him to have full autonomy and
appoint more than a dozen Spanish staff.
Villa’s poor start to the season and transfer window would,
therefore, not have gone unnoticed, especially when he and fellow co-owners are
footing the costs for UEFA fines incurred for breaching the European governing
body’s financial regulations.
As part of UEFA’s Squad Cost Rules (SCR), Villa had to lower
their wage-to-revenue ratio to 70 per cent or lower in the summer, down from
the mid-80s at the end of last season. They were also mindful of UEFA’s
Football Earnings Rule (FER), which states clubs can lose no more than €60m
(£51.6m; $70.1m) over that period. The Athletic projects
that Villa are still operating above the 70 per cent SCR limit and
will be at risk of incurring a fine this season.
Those financial restrictions contributed to the challenging
summer transfer window, which saw Villa miss out on a host of first-choice
targets. Senior figures such as Vidagany and Monchi were constantly
firefighting and also had to placate Emery’s desires to improve the squad.
Villa have signed 28 senior players since Emery’s arrival.
PSR concerns have influenced some of those acquisitions, particularly those
involving separate cross-player transactions with other clubs, but their impact
has not been as great as expected and Villa have been left with an ageing
squad. As one source close to a player put it to The Athletic, “They
have spent all this money and have nothing to show for it.”
Monchi’s departure raises more fundamental questions over
how Villa are structured and whether his replacement, almost certainly Olabe,
should be as closely aligned to Emery.
Emery is Villa’s best manager in the modern era and few
close observers will bet against him turning around on-pitch fortunes and the
present flat mood encompassing the club. But with Villa having grown stagnant,
in part owing to recent additions failing to make an impact, change was deemed
to be necessary.
Comments
Post a Comment