Can one be too frugal and sensible in football? Is Luton Town a case in point? Here are some highlights from the Swiss Ramble’s analysis using his Zurich data hoard. Much more on his Substack page.
Overall, things have clearly taken a turn for the worse on
the pitch, but the club’s finances look in pretty good shape. The club’s sustainable strategy resulted in
limited expenditure on the squad after promotion to the top flight. Instead,
the club invested much of the windfall gains in building a new stadium.
This continued after relegation with around 20% of the money
generated from the Premier League campaign and the subsequent parachute
payments going to the Power Court stadium project. In addition, the club had to spend money on
improvements to Kenilworth Road, including the new Bobbers Stand, in order to
comply with Premier League requirements.
As a result, they had a hefty £44m of capital expenditure in the last
two seasons, including £25m in 2024/25 alone.
This was easily the highest infrastructure investment in the
Championship that season, almost twice as much as Stoke City £13.0m and Leeds
United £12.3m. For more perspective, no fewer than 16 clubs spent less than £5m
here.
While such investment will be beneficial to Luton’s
long-term prospects, it is evident that it has made it more difficult to
compete on the pitch. This has undoubtedly had an adverse impact on the second
part of the club’s stated strategy, namely “to remain competitive at the
highest levels of the game”.
This was evidenced during their brief stay in the Premier
League, when their £27m gross transfer spend was nowhere near what is required
to have a reasonable chance of competing. It was easily the lowest in the top
flight in 2023/24, a long way below Wolves £47m and Sheffield United £53m. Similarly,
Luton’s £57m wage bill that season was also by far the smallest in the Premier
League. Only Sheffield United came anywhere close with £64m, but the third
lowest, Burnley, paid considerably more with £93m.
Despite relegation, Luton still posted a sizeable £17.9m
pre-tax profit in 2024/25, albeit well down from the previous season’s £49.5m
in the Premier League. Revenue virtually
halved in the Championship, falling £65.5m from £132.3m to £66.8m, though this
was partially offset by lower operating expenses, which dropped £17.9m (21%)
from £84.9m to £67.0m, and a steep increase in profit on player sales from just
£1.2m to £17.2m.
Luton’s revenue obviously fell significantly after
relegation from the Premier League, but their £66.8m was almost four times as
much as the last time they were in the Championship two years earlier, thanks
to the parachute payment.
Most of the year-on-year reduction logically came in
broadcast income, though this remained the most important revenue stream,
accounting for an incredible 84% of total revenue, while match day and
commercial only contributed 9% and 7% respectively. Even after the steep decrease following
relegation, Luton’s £67m revenue was still the fourth highest in the
Championship, only behind Leeds United’s exceptional £137m, Sheffield United
£79m and Burnley £72m.
Following relegation, Luton’s commercial income more than
halved, dropping from £9.5m to £4.5m, mainly due to lower sponsorships Luton’s £4.5m commercial income was one of
the lowest in the Championship, only above Millwall £4.0m, Oxford United £3.9m
and Preston North End £3.3m. This was miles below the likes of Leeds United
£58m, Bristol City £20m and Stoke City £18m. in the Championship, though this
was still the second highest ever for the club.
Luton’s match day income fell £0.1m (1%) from £6.2m to
£6.1m, which has to be considered a very good result after dropping down to the
Championship, especially given the poor performances on the pitch, though one
additional game was staged at Kenilworth Road.
Nevertheless, Luton’s £6.1m match day revenue firmly in the bottom half
of the Championship, a fair way below Leeds United, whose £31.6m was in a class
of its own in this division, as well as Sunderland £13.3m, Sheffield United
£13.1m and Coventry City £12.2m.
Luton’s 11,552 attendance was the second lowest in the
Championship, only above Oxford United 11,358. This was miles below Sunderland
41,158, Leeds United 36,134, Derby County 29,018 and Sheffield United 28,091. Their attendance was eighth highest in League
One last season, though only around half of Bolton Wanderers 21,692, Bradford
City 20,444 and Cardiff City 19,564.
Luton have been investing significant sums into a new 25,000
capacity stadium at Power Court, which is expected to open for the start of the
2028/29 season.
Wages
Luton’s wages fell by nearly a third, falling £17.4m from
£56.9m to £39.5m, as relegation clauses helped mitigate the reduction in
revenue, while some of the higher earners departed. Some left for free or on
loan, which did not generate anything in player sales, but did help lower the
wage bill. Nevertheless, Luton’s £39.5m
wages were still much higher than their £27.6m two years earlier in the
Championship, even though that season included a sizeable promotion bonus. Even after the steep reduction, Luton’s £40m
wage bill was still sixth highest in the Championship, only behind the three
clubs that went up
Luton massively underperformed their wages in 2024/25, as
their finishing position of 22nd in the league was 17 places worse than their
wages ranking of 5th. Only Cardiff City did worse on this basis. Luton’s 59% wages to turnover ratio in
2024/25 was the ninth best in the whole of England, vividly illustrating their
commitment to sustainability.
Interestingly, Luton spent more on player purchases after
relegation than in the Premier League, as their £27.6m outlay in 2024/25 was
slightly higher than the previous season’s £26.8m. Both seasons were around
four times as much as the old club record of £6.8m in 2022/23.
Although Luton’s owners have provided the club with £39m
since 2014/15, no money has been required in the last five seasons, thanks to
the growth in income, allied with the frugal approach.
It could be argued that they never really gave themselves a
fighting chance of survival in the top flight, as they spent very little on the
squad, while paying far lower wages than anyone else.
That being said, they should really have done much better in
the Championship, as their wages and transfer spend placed them in the play-off
places, as opposed to the relegation they suffered. It would have been a
similar story in League One last season, when they (narrowly) missed out on the
play-offs.
All of this is perfectly understandable from the perspective
of sustainability, though two consecutive relegations make less sense.
Ultimately, the new stadium at Power Court should help
Luton’s ability to compete, bringing in new revenue streams, while the
distribution reforms supported by the Independent Financial Regulator should
also help.
Comments
Post a Comment