Skip to main content

Will competition law offer an escape route for City?

There have been a number of brushes between football governance arrangements and competition law and a new one has just opened up.   The essential issue is whether football competitions are run as de facto cartels to benefit existing providers and are therefore potentially illegal.

The Union of European Clubs (UEC) has challenged the exclusive relationship between UEFA and European Football Clubs (EFC), the body formerly known as the European Club Association, in a complaint to the European Commission.

Set up in 2023 to represent the interests of non-elite clubs, the UEC is asking the European Union’s executive branch to investigate whether the UEFA/EFC Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) breaches EU competition law.

Under the terms of the MoU, which was first agreed in 2008 and then renewed in October 2024 until July 2033, UEFA recognises the EFC as “the sole body” representing clubs. The UEC believes this is anti-competitive and an abuse of market dominance.

The complaint was prepared with advice from Professor Miguel Poiares Maduro, a former advocate general at the European Court of Justice and ex-chairman of FIFA’s Governance Committee.

Mauduro said in a press release: “A system where a select group of elite clubs is given the power to decide who gets to compete in European competitions, and how the revenues are distributed, does not only harm competition in European and national football. It gradually destroys the model of open and balanced competition that UEFA itself claims to protect.”

Whether the commission will start a formal investigation remains to be seen but we can be fairly sure that it will not do so quickly, as it is still mulling over a 2024 complaint from Europe’s top leagues against FIFA for the global governing body’s alleged abusive conduct. The commission has traditionally tried to stay out of sport’s disputes.

The UK is no longer a member of the EU, but its domestic competition law is broadly similar, although more influenced by American anti-trust legislation.  Manchester City could challenge any findings in the form of sanctions as a breach of competition law.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

It's no deal say Spurs insiders over Taiwanese takeover

Senior figures at Tottenham Hotspur insisted on Friday that they had not been informed of any deal to sell Daniel Levy’s stake in the club. A business group, Eight Sports Capital — which is said to include a billionaire Taiwanese financier — claimed that it had an agreement in place to buy a 24.99 per cent stake in ENIC, the club’s majority owners, from Levy, who owns 29.88 per cent. The Times has been told Ng Wing Fai and Brooklyn Earick form part of the group, having both been linked previously to potential takeovers of the Premier League club. The Taiwanese businessman, Richard Tsai, is also said to be part of the consortium. He is reportedly worth £7 billion.  Last year Earick, the former DJ and tech entrepreneur, was part of an attempted £4.5 billion takeover, which was “unequivocally rejected” by Spurs.  An ENIC spokesperson said: “We can confirm that neither ENIC nor THFC are aware of any sale by Daniel Levy’s Family Trust of its minority stake in ENIC, THFC’...

Reports about Charlton sale exaggerated

Reports have appeared in The Guardian and elsewhere that Charlton has been put up for sale. Richard Cawley is an authoritative local journalist who runs a South London Sport substack site.  He reached out to the club yesterday evening to ask for comment on The Guardian’s article. Early indications from the club have been that nothing has changed since the story about them seeking investment, except that it is now a different company doing it. Charlton have since managed to consolidate their place in the Championship, avoiding an instant return to League One, with their women’s side promoted to the WSL, returning to the top flight for the first time since 2007, although staying there is likely to be costly. It would be counter-intuitive for owners Global Football Partners not to progress the club when looking for investment, that the focus remains on driving it forward, that their spend this summer is in line with long-term planning and will see an increase in wages spent on players...

Levy's anomalous status at Spurs

It is now nearly a year since Daniel Levy was dismissed as Tottenham Hotspur chairman by the Lewis family.  It has been 12 months of dramatic twists and turns, with Spurs avoiding relegation on the final day of the Premier League season, and then spending unprecedented sums this summer to try to make sure such a scare never happens again. But while most fans focus on the football — and a dubbing by Brentford   — another set of issues have been bubbling away separately. These relate to Levy’s continued position as a minority shareholder in the club. This has been in the news for much of this summer, even as we approach the first anniversary of Levy’s dismissal, and specifically this month, after he missed the opportunity last week to participate in the Lewis family’s latest equity injection into the club. On Thursday morning the club confirmed that his shareholding has been diluted, down by roughly two per cent, after the creation of new ENIC shares. Levy’s dism...